Pin it
This homemade custard hits all the right notes—silky, luxurious, and packed with genuine vanilla goodness that makes you want to pour it on everything in sight. Using only eggs as the thickener—no shortcuts with cornstarch—it's an authentic pouring custard (also called Creme Anglaise) that's surprisingly simple to make. You'll wonder why you ever bought the packaged stuff. The texture sticks beautifully to your spoon and tastes like pure comfort food. Whip this up in around 20 minutes for a special touch on your fruit bowls, pies, or cakes.
I brought this to a family dinner last year and it was sneakily popular—everyone kept dipping spoons straight into the container when they thought nobody was looking. Even my super-picky cousin said it was way better than anything from the grocery store. These days I always keep vanilla beans in my pantry just for this recipe—it's become our family tradition.
Essential Ingredients
- Vanilla Bean: Worth every penny if you can swing it—it's what gives this custard its soul with those warm, floral hints. You can use paste or extract in a pinch, but nothing beats the real thing.
- Heavy Cream: Pick thickened cream (at least 35% fat)—it creates that gorgeous richness. You can use lighter cream, but you'll miss out on the full experience.
- Milk: Stick with whole milk for the right balance—don't go fat-free or you'll end up with watery results. Just warm it gently for that cozy feel.
- Egg Yolks: Three yolks bring the magic thickness—farm-fresh ones really pop with better color and flavor.
- Sugar: Superfine sugar dissolves quicker, but standard granulated works too—just enough to sweeten without going overboard.
I'm completely hooked on using real vanilla beans here—they're totally worth the extra cost. I ran out once and used extract instead, and while it was decent, the bean version just feels more special. My little ones get excited watching me scrape out those tiny seeds—they always say the kitchen smells like a bakery.
Simple Cooking Steps
- Step 1: Handle the Vanilla
- Take your knife and cut the vanilla bean down the middle. Scrape out all those tiny black specks—they're flavor bombs. Throw both seeds and pod into your saucepan with 1 cup heavy cream and ¼ cup milk.
- Step 2: Heat Everything Up
- Put the pan on medium heat until you see tiny bubbles forming around the edges. Take it off and let it sit for 5 minutes so it cools down a bit.
- Step 3: Mix the Sweet Base
- While that's happening, beat 3 egg yolks with ¼ cup sugar in a bowl for about 2 minutes until you get a pale, fluffy mixture—put some muscle into it.
- Step 4: Join Everything Together
- Remove the vanilla pod (don't toss it!) and slowly pour the warm cream into the egg mix while whisking constantly—go really slow to prevent scrambling. Then pour everything back into your pan.
- Step 5: Cook It Right
- Return to low heat (medium-low for electric stoves). Keep whisking for 3 minutes straight, then continue stirring almost constantly for another 5 minutes until it's thick enough to coat your spoon—you should be able to draw a line through it. Don't let it bubble or you'll get lumps.
- Step 6: Final Touches
- Remove from heat. For the smoothest result, pour through a fine strainer. Let it cool a bit—it'll get thicker as it sits.
Pin it
The heavy cream really makes this something special—it's what creates that treat-yourself feeling. Once my sister caught me drowning some day-old apple pie in this custard, and now she asks me to make extra batches whenever she visits. It's become our favorite way to upgrade any dessert.
Delicious Serving Ideas
Try pouring it over hot pancakes or waffles for a fancy breakfast treat that'll wow everyone. I've used it between layers of berries in a trifle and couldn't believe how good it was. Even plain fruit becomes restaurant-worthy with just a drizzle on top.
Pin it
Storage Advice
Pop it in the fridge in a tight container for up to 3 days—it'll thicken up more while chilling. Just give it a quick whisk before you use it again to smooth it out. When I have leftovers, I warm them up slowly on low heat with a splash of milk, and they come back to life perfectly.
Creative Variations
Sometimes I add a tiny bit of almond extract along with the vanilla for a nutty twist that works amazingly well. Another fun idea is mixing in some mashed raspberries right at the end for pretty pink swirls. My neighbor swears by adding a dash of cardamom—it gives an unexpected warm spice note.
Great Combinations
This custard works magic with a hot apple crisp—the contrast of temperatures just hits different. During the holidays, I pour it generously over warm bread pudding to rave reviews. Even the plainest cake becomes something memorable with this silky topping.
Pin it
This custard can transform ordinary desserts into something people won't forget—velvety, indulgent, and surprisingly simple to make. It shows how basic ingredients can become something truly special with just a bit of love. Try it once, and the store-bought version will never cut it again.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What if I don’t have vanilla beans?
- Go for a teaspoon of vanilla paste or extract instead.
- → How do I know it’s thick enough?
- Once it coats the back of your spoon, it’s done.
- → Can you freeze custard?
- Nope, better fresh or chilled for a couple of days.
- → Is this easy for beginners?
- Totally! Just whisk often and keep the heat low.
- → What can I serve it with?
- It’s lovely with fresh fruit or a slice of apple cake.