Pin it
These little treats melt right in your mouth and go by loads of different names worldwide, but no matter what you call them, their buttery goodness and sweet powdery coating make them impossible to resist. My grandma always named them Sugar Butter Balls, and they've been a special part of our family's holiday get-togethers for as long as I can remember.
When I brought these to a cookie swap last Christmas, I hadn't even gotten home before three people texted asking how to make them! There's just something about that combo of buttery cookie and sweet powdery coating that gets everyone hooked.
Key Ingredients and Smart Picks
- Butter - Grab unsalted butter and let it soften for easier mixing
- Powdered Sugar - Makes the dough extra soft and coats without any grittiness
- Vanilla Extract - Go for the real stuff instead of imitation for tastier results
- All-Purpose Flour - The main building block for these simple cookies
- Nuts - Tiny bits of pecans or walnuts really bump up the taste and feel
The real wonder happens when you roll those warm cookies in powdered sugar, making that sweet layer that practically vanishes on your tongue with every bite.
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- Step 1: Make the Dough
- Beat the soft butter with powdered sugar and vanilla until it's fluffy and pale. Mix in flour and salt bit by bit, stopping once it's just combined so you don't toughen the dough. Fold in the finely chopped nuts until they're spread throughout.
- Step 2: Form the Cookies
- Take small scoops of dough, about 1-inch each, and roll them between your hands into neat balls. Put them on a baking sheet lined with parchment, keeping them about an inch apart since they won't grow much in the oven.
- Step 3: Bake Them Right
- Pop them in a 400°F oven for 10-12 minutes until they're set but not turning brown. The cookies should feel firm when touched but stay pretty pale. Keep a close eye on them since too long in the oven makes them dry out.
- Step 4: Sugar Coating Time
- Let the cookies sit on the sheet for about a minute, then roll each warm one in powdered sugar. Their warmth helps that first sugar layer stick and slightly melt into the cookie.
- Step 5: Let Them Cool Off
- Put the sugar-covered cookies on a rack and wait until they're totally room temperature. This waiting part really matters before you add more sugar.
- Step 6: Add More Sugar
- Once they're fully cool, roll them in powdered sugar again once or twice to get that pretty snow-white look. This final coating sticks better to cool cookies and gives them that perfect sweet outside.
Pin it
The Rich History Behind Traditional Treats
These cookies mean a lot in many cultures around the world. Some call them Russian Tea Cakes in Eastern Europe while they're known as Polvorones in Mexico. They often show up at weddings and parties as symbols of purity and happiness. The white sugar coating stands for fresh starts, which is why they fit so well at holiday parties when we think about the old year and look ahead to what's coming next.
Wonderful Ways to Give These Treats
Everyone loves getting these cookies as gifts. I pack them in pretty tins with colorful tissue paper, making them look extra special for the holidays. They don't break easily when moved around and stay fresh for quite a while, so they're great for mailing to family far away or taking to holiday parties.
Pin it
Sweet Moments From Years Gone By
I can still see my grandma's hands when I think about these cookies. Her fingers moved so carefully but quickly, rolling each ball just right. I'd stand right next to her, waiting for her to smile and sneak me a warm cookie. That amazing soft feeling in my mouth and then the little cloud of sugar that made us both giggle is still one of my favorite memories from when I was little.
Family Twists on a Classic
My grandma's way of making these is still my favorite, but I've tried so many different versions from friends and relatives over the years. Some folks add a bit of cinnamon or almond flavor, while others mix in some lemon zest for a fresh kick. In Mexico, they often throw in some anise seed for a slight licorice taste. Every family tweaks the basic idea to make it their own special version to hand down to kids and grandkids.
Important Things to Remember
- Be gentle with the dough or you'll end up with tough cookies
- Pull them out as soon as they're done but before they brown
- Do the first sugar roll while they're still warm
- Wait till they're totally cool for the last sugar coating
- Keep them in a sealed container so they stay fresh longer
When I first tried making these at 18, I thought I could save time by tossing the cookies in a bag with sugar instead of rolling them one by one. Big mistake! Half of them crumbled! Turns out my grandma's careful hand-rolling method really does work best.
Pro Baker Shortcuts
- Cut those nuts super tiny for the best texture
- Spoon flour into your measuring cups instead of digging in
- Make sure your butter isn't cold when you start mixing
- Let cookies cool just a minute or two before sugar coating
- Try adding a tiny bit of food color to the sugar for parties
Pin it
Mexican Wedding Cookies have become my holiday trademark now. Everyone knows I'll bring them to parties or give them as presents. They're so easy to make that my kids can help too, keeping the tradition going just like my grandma did with me.
Last-Minute Advice
- Make extra because they'll vanish fast
- They'll stay good for about a week in a sealed container
- You can freeze them before adding sugar for up to 3 months
- Use baking paper between layers when giving as gifts
- They taste amazing with hot tea or coffee to balance the sweetness
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What nuts are best for these?
- Pecans are a go-to choice, but you could use walnuts instead.
- → Why coat them in sugar twice?
- It helps the sugar stick when warm and locks in sweetness once cooled.
- → Can I store these in the freezer?
- Definitely! Save them for up to 3 months before that last sugar layer.
- → What’s the story behind the name?
- They’re often served at festive events like Mexican weddings because they look celebratory!
- → How small should the nuts be chopped?
- Super fine, like tiny grains—but not powdered to keep some texture.