Pin it
Take a bite of these luscious treats that blend the rich taste of brownies with the sweet comfort of banana pudding. These Banana Pudding Brownies mix fudgy chocolate goodness with smooth homemade vanilla custard, fresh bananas, and crunchy vanilla wafers. When I bake these, my kitchen fills with sweet vanilla scents and caramelized banana aromas, taking me back to lazy summer days enjoying my grandma's banana pudding on her porch.
I took a batch to our family picnic last week, and even my picky nieces who won't touch fruit gobbled them up. What's the trick? The bananas keep the brownies super moist while the pudding adds that creamy sweetness that nobody can resist.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Bananas - Pick ones with dark speckles for maximum sweetness. I've noticed that bananas you might think are too soft for snacking work best in this recipe
- Vanilla Wafer Cookies - Make sure they're fresh from the package. Stale cookies will stand out in a bad way. I typically grab two boxes because I can't stop munching while I cook
- Brown Sugar - Either light or dark works great, though dark gives more caramel notes. Keep it soft by tossing in a bread slice with it
- Butter - Stick with unsalted so you can manage the saltiness yourself. Let it sit out until soft for the smoothest pudding texture
- Vanilla Extract - Go for real vanilla instead of imitation for both the pudding and brownie mix
I've learned from making these dozens of times that you need to measure your mashed bananas carefully - too many makes them too fluffy and cake-like, while skimping means you'll miss that classic banana pudding taste.
Step-By-Step Baking Method
- 1. Creating Your Custard
- First tackle the vanilla pudding - heat milk in a thick-bottomed pot over medium flame. In another bowl, mix sugar, flour, and egg yolks until they're light yellow. The trick is slowly adding the warm milk into this mixture while constantly whisking - I once rushed this and ended up with sweet scrambled eggs! Pour everything back into the pot and stir non-stop until it's thick enough to coat your spoon, usually around 5-7 minutes.
- 2. Making Brownie Mixture
- While your pudding cools down, start on the brownie base. Melt your butter just until it's liquid but not hot. Blend with both types of sugar until smooth. Now comes the fun part - add your mashed ripe bananas and watch the texture change completely. Add the egg yolk and vanilla, mixing until it looks shiny and smooth.
- 3. Adding Dry Components
- Sift together your flour, baking powder, and salt - this helps prevent lumps and spreads everything evenly. Gently fold these dry ingredients into your wet mix, stopping right when you don't see any more flour streaks. Don't overdo the mixing or you'll lose that fudgy texture.
- 4. Building Your Layers
- Now let's create those beautiful strata. Spread half the brownie mix into your pan - I use a spoon back to get it even. Push a layer of vanilla wafers into this batter, setting up that classic banana pudding feel.
- 5. Finishing Touches
- Drop spoonfuls of remaining brownie mix and cooled pudding in a checkerboard pattern. Then run a knife through it making swirly patterns - I prefer s-shapes for the prettiest marbling.
Pin it
While testing different versions, my little girl suggested we sprinkle crushed wafers on top before baking for extra crunch. She was totally right - sometimes kids come up with the best cooking ideas!
Pin it
Mastering Oven Settings
Getting your oven temperature just right matters a lot. I keep a thermometer inside mine to check it's actually hitting 350°F. When done, the middle should still wobble slightly when you pull them out - it'll firm up as it cools down.
Getting Perfect Consistency
The toothpick check works differently with these treats because of the pudding swirls. You want to see some moist crumbs from brownie parts, while pudding areas will stay creamy and wet.
Keeping Them Fresh
These taste even better the day after baking once all the flavors mix together. Keep them covered at room temperature and they'll stay good for about 3 days.
Insider Baking Secrets
- Always use parchment paper with extra hanging over the sides for easy lifting. I learned this the hard way after destroying my first batch trying to scoop them out
- Eggs blend better when they're not cold from the fridge. I pop mine in warm water for a few minutes if I forget to set them out early
- Don't overdo the swirling or you'll lose the distinct pudding and brownie sections
Pin it
Closing Thoughts
These Banana Pudding Brownies truly give you the best of both worlds - rich fudgy brownies plus the homey comfort of banana pudding. They've become my favorite thing to bring to gatherings, not just because they taste amazing, but because they bring back happy memories for everyone who tries them. I get better at making them each time as I learn new tricks, but the simple magic of mixing these two desserts never fails to wow people.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why is flour measurement important?
- Too much flour makes brownies dry - measure by spooning it into a cup or use a scale.
- → Can instant pudding work?
- Homemade is best, but instant pudding is a quick backup option.
- → How ripe do bananas need to be?
- Choose spotted bananas as they’re extra sweet and flavorful.
- → Are these freezable?
- Yes, keep them fresh for up to a month in a sealed container.
- → Why didn’t mine turn out fudgy?
- Overdoing the flour is often the issue - watch your measurements!