Pin it
Sitting by the campfire toasting marshmallows, breaking chocolate bars, and munching graham crackers creates summer memories we all cherish. This frozen S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll takes those familiar campfire treats and turns them into an impressive cold dessert everyone will want more of. What makes it special? The amazing layers - chewy cookie dough wrapped around smooth vanilla ice cream, packed with all the classic s'mores goodies we can't get enough of.
When I brought this to our backyard cookout last year, it vanished in moments. Kids couldn't stop staring at the cool swirled pattern, and adults kept asking for my secret recipe. Even my nephew who usually turns down sweets came back asking for another slice.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice:
- Whole milk and heavy cream: The fat is what makes your ice cream silky instead of icy. Skip the low-fat versions or you'll end up with an icy texture
- Oven-treated flour: Bake it until it hits 165°F so it's safe to eat raw. This light toasting also adds a yummy nutty flavor
- Mini chocolate chips: These tiny bits spread better through the dough than big chunks and make rolling much easier. Get good quality ones that melt smoothly
- Mini marshmallows: Always pick the freshest pack - stale ones get hard and won't melt right when heated
Simple Step-by-Step Cooking Guide:
- Getting the cookie dough ready
- Whip your butter until it's super fluffy - give it about 3 minutes. This creates little air bubbles for softer dough
- Mix in both sugars slowly, beating until everything looks like damp sand
- Add vanilla and egg just until mixed - too much mixing will make tough dough
- Use a spatula to gently fold in your baked flour mix, stopping once you can't see dry spots
- Making your ice cream base
- Mix the cream, milk and sugar until all sugar melts away
- Add this mixture to your cold ice cream maker
- Take your time churning - going too fast ruins the texture
- It's done when it looks like soft-serve and holds its shape
- Setting up your workspace
- Make room in your freezer before you start
- Spread out parchment paper bigger than your planned roll
- Put cookie dough between two sheets of parchment to roll it without sticking
- Keep churning your ice cream until you're completely ready for it
- How to roll it up
- Move fast but carefully when you spread the ice cream
- Keep that important 1-inch edge empty to stop overflow
- Let the parchment help you by lifting it slowly
- Got a tear? Just press it together with your fingers
- Squeeze gently while rolling to push out air bubbles
Pin it
I've learned that browning the marshmallows adds so much more flavor. My kid always hangs around the kitchen hoping for the broken bits that don't make it into the final dessert. That smoky marshmallow smell fills the house and takes us back to family camping trips and evening gatherings in the yard.
Mastering Temperature Tricks:
Getting each part to the right temperature makes or breaks this dessert. The cookie dough can't be too warm or too cold when you roll it. I figured this out after many tries - it should feel like play dough when you touch it.
Building Perfect Layers:
Making this roll works a lot like putting together a great sandwich - you want good stuff in every bite. I sprinkle the graham bits in three small batches instead of dumping them all at once. I picked up this trick from years of making rolled desserts.
Fun Ways to Serve It:
Let this roll be the star of your dessert table. I like to cut it beforehand and arrange the pieces in a circle, then pour warm chocolate sauce over everything just as we eat. The hot sauce hitting the cold ice cream creates this amazing taste moment.
Pin it
Keeping It Fresh:
After trying lots of different ways to store this dessert, I found that wrapping it twice - first in parchment, then with plastic wrap - works best to keep it from getting freezer burn. Taking that extra minute to wrap it right pays off in better taste later.
In all my time cooking, this S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll remains the dessert people ask for most. It mixes the fun of childhood snacks with a fancy look that works for any party. It does take some effort to make, but seeing everyone's happy faces when they taste it makes it worth every minute. Just remember to follow each step without rushing and don't worry if it's not perfectly shaped - it'll still taste amazing.
Tasty Twists to Try:
What I love most about this dessert is how easy it is to change up. Try using chocolate, peanut butter, or coffee ice cream instead of vanilla for a whole new taste. Want to make it even more decadent? Pour some caramel or hot fudge over the finished roll. You can even play with the cookie base - maybe use chocolate chip cookie dough or brownie batter for something really rich.
Why That Swirl Works So Well:
That pretty swirl pattern isn't just for looks - it makes sure you get all the flavors in each bite. The trick is working quickly while the ice cream is soft but not runny. When you push those graham crumbs into the ice cream before rolling, you're actually creating a barrier that stops the ice cream from making the cookie dough soggy.
Getting the Best Marshmallow Flavor:
Mini marshmallows work great because they spread evenly, but regular marshmallows can create bigger pockets of gooey goodness. If you go with the big ones, try putting them under the broiler for a minute to get that toasty flavor that makes real s'mores so good. Just let them cool a bit before adding them to your ice cream or they'll melt it too fast.
Pin it
Making More for Big Groups:
Need to feed a crowd? Just double or triple everything and use bigger parchment paper for rolling. If you're making several rolls, you can prep the cookie dough and ice cream ahead of time and keep them separate in the fridge until you're ready to put them together. This saves a ton of time when you're planning a big party.
Making It Look Amazing:
How this dessert looks matters almost as much as how it tastes. Cut even slices and arrange them in a spiral on your serving plate. Drizzle warm chocolate or caramel on top, then sprinkle extra graham bits or toasted marshmallows. A few berries or mint leaves add nice color. Your goal is a dessert that looks so good people can't wait to try it.
From what I've seen firsthand, this S'mores Explosion Cookie Dough Ice Cream Roll is more than just something sweet to eat - it's a whole experience. It takes you back to summer nights telling stories around the campfire. It brings people together and creates memories they'll talk about later. Whether you're making it for a birthday or just because it's Saturday, give it a try. You might just find your new favorite treat.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use store-bought ice cream?
- Of course! While homemade ice cream feels extra special, good-quality store-bought ice cream works just as well.
- → How long should it freeze?
- At least 4 hours for it to fully set, but leaving it overnight gives the best texture.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
- You bet! Wrap it tightly and freeze it up to a week ahead—it'll stay delicious.
- → Why are mini chocolate chips better?
- Tiny chips spread more evenly, giving each slice its perfect chocolate balance.
- → Can I toast marshmallows for this?
- Sure thing! Toasted marshmallows bring a real campfire vibe—just let them cool before adding.