Mini Cheesecake Jars

These bite-sized sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes deliver a dreamy mix of creamy goodness in handy, personal portions. The smooth, luscious cheesecake filling sitting on a buttery graham base makes an addictive dessert that feels fancy yet homey. Using sweetened condensed milk instead of regular sugar gives these little treats an incredibly smooth feel that makes them stand out from run-of-the-mill cheesecakes. I whipped these up for my kid's graduation bash just last week. Everyone loved having their own little dessert, and many folks asked me how I made them. What makes them so special? The sweetened condensed milk adds this amazing creaminess you just can't get with plain sugar.

Key Ingredients

• Cream Cheese: Go for the full-fat kind at room temp. I've found that cold cream cheese makes lumps, and low-fat versions just don't have the right feel
• Sweetened Condensed Milk: This wonder ingredient brings sweetness and smoothness together. Stick with full-fat for the most indulgent results
• Graham Crackers: Pick fresh, crunchy ones for the best base. I like honey grahams for their gentle sweetness
• Eggs: They've gotta be room temperature to mix in properly. Cold eggs might make your batter separate
• Extracts: Mixing vanilla with lemon creates amazing flavor layers. Real extracts really do taste better

From my years of cheesecake baking, I've noticed that ingredient temperature is super important. When everything's at room temp, it all blends together smoothly and gives you that velvety texture we're going for.

Simple Step-by-Step Guide

1. Making Your Base

• Smash graham crackers until you get tiny, uniform crumbs
• Stir with melted butter until it looks like damp sand
• Put exactly one tablespoon in each jar for even results
• Push down lightly with a spoon, but don't pack too hard

2. Mixing Your Filling

• Whip cream cheese by itself until it's completely smooth, roughly 3 minutes
• Clean your bowl and beaters thoroughly between adding ingredients
• Add sweetened condensed milk in a slow stream while mixing
• Mix in eggs one by one, just enough to blend them
• Add extracts with gentle folding to keep everything smooth

3. Cooking The Topping

• Clean strawberries and remove stems, cutting big ones into pieces
• Mix with sugar, cornstarch, water, and lemon juice in a pot
• Warm slowly and stir often to avoid clumps
• Squish berries slightly as they cook for natural chunks
• Cook until the sauce gets thick enough to coat a spoon, around 5-8 minutes

4. Putting It Together

• Use a measuring scoop to fill each jar evenly
• Don't fill to the top - save room for sauce and toppings
• Tap jars softly to let air bubbles escape
• Wipe jar edges with a wet paper towel before baking

5. Baking Technique

• Set jars on a baking sheet with edges for safety
• Pour hot water into the pan halfway up the jars for a water bath
• Bake at 300°F - getting the right temperature is key
• They're done when the center still wiggles slightly

Pin it

My grandma always told me to tap each jar before baking to get rid of air bubbles. She claimed patience was the hidden ingredient in any good cheesecake, and after making these tons of times, I totally get what she meant.

Pin it

Mastering Cheesecake Skills

Getting that perfect texture means understanding how everything works together. The sweetened condensed milk gives both sweetness and structure, while careful mixing keeps everything silky smooth.

Keeping and Eating

These tiny treats stay good in the fridge for up to five days. Their individual size makes them perfect for parties since everyone can grab their own without any cutting or serving issues.

Pin it

Warm Ingredients Work Best

Using room temperature stuff isn't just a random suggestion. It's really important for avoiding lumps and helping everything bake evenly. I learned this the hard way when I rushed once and used cold cream cheese that left tiny lumps all over.

Pro Cooking Advice

• Check if they're done by giving the pan a little shake - centers should move slightly
• Let them cool completely before adding any toppings or you'll get water drops
• When storing, keep lids a bit loose so moisture doesn't build up

I've tweaked this recipe for years and found that these mini treats bring all the joy of big cheesecakes but they're way more practical and cute. The single servings work great for sharing, and you can top them with almost anything. They're fancy enough for special events with fresh fruit on top but simple enough for a weeknight dessert on their own.

Pin it

Closing Thoughts

These mini sweetened condensed milk cheesecakes show what's great about home cooking - they're easy but still fancy, traditional yet modern, and they bring people together. After making countless batches in my kitchen, I've realized their appeal isn't just about the creamy texture or handy size, but how they create moments of connection. Each little jar shows care and attention to detail. What started as a way to avoid cutting slices turned into one of my favorite recipes. The mix of silky filling with crunchy graham base topped with bright strawberry sauce creates something both familiar and special. While the steps aren't complicated, it's the small things - warm ingredients, gentle mixing, exact oven temp - that turn these mini cheesecakes from good to amazing.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prep them early?

Yep, make them up to 2 days early. Store in the fridge and add the topping before you serve.

→ What jar size works best?

Go for those small 4-ounce mason jars. They’re just the right size for single portions.

→ Why mix eggs slowly?

Keeping the speed low stops air bubbles. Too much air might cause cracks.

→ Can I switch the topping?

Totally! Try caramel or another fruit topping instead—it’s up to you.

→ How long are these good for?

Fridge-stored cheesecakes last 5 days. Without topping, they’re freezer-safe for 3 months.