Pin it
Capture the magic of campfire treats in these mouth-watering S'mores Cookies. Each bite brings together a soft cookie base, gooey chocolate, and puffy marshmallows, letting you enjoy that outdoor feeling whenever you want, no matter what season it is.
I started baking these for my kid's scout meetings last year, and now they beg for them every time. It's really something to watch those marshmallows turn that golden-brown color under the broiler, just like when we toast them outside.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Butter: Go with unsalted butter that's slightly soft - you should be able to press it and leave a small dent
- Graham Crackers: Make sure they're not old and soft - you need that fresh snap for proper crumbs
- Chocolate: Pick good milk chocolate that melts nicely, such as Hershey's or Ghirardelli bars
- Marshmallows: The tiny ones work way better since they spread out evenly and melt faster
Pin it
Simple Cooking Instructions
- Getting the Base Just Right
- Beat butter with sugars until they're puffy and pale, taking about 3-4 minutes
- Drop in eggs separately, mixing completely before adding the next
- Quit stirring right when you can't see flour anymore or you'll end up with hard cookies
- Making Sure They Turn Out Perfect
- Let the dough cool in the fridge until it feels solid
- Drop equal amounts using a cookie scoop
- Put them far apart because they'll grow while baking
- Finishing With Style
- Add your toppings fast while cookies are still hot
- Keep your eyes on them during broiling - they'll burn super fast
- Wait until they're totally cool before you pack them up
Pin it
S'mores were always the highlight when we went camping as kids. Now these cookies bring back those good times while we make fresh memories at home.
This has turned into our go-to baking project when it's pouring outside, giving us that summer feeling even when we're stuck indoors.
What I love most about these treats is how they turn a simple campfire snack into something you'd be proud to bring to any party.
The way everything comes together - soft cookie, crispy graham bits, and sticky marshmallow - makes something nobody can turn down.
After making batch after batch and watching everyone's happy faces, I'm convinced these s'mores cookies are the best way to enjoy campfire flavors without leaving your kitchen.
Tasty Serving Ideas
Make these cookies extra special by eating them while they're still a bit warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. For get-togethers, I've made "s'mores cookie sandwiches" by putting chocolate ice cream between two cookies. During Christmas and Thanksgiving, try adding a little caramel drizzle for something fancy.
Pin it
Keeping Them Fresh
These cookies taste best if you eat them within three days, but you can make them last by:
- Putting raw dough balls in the freezer for up to 3 months
- Putting wax paper between layers of baked cookies
- Using containers that seal tight and keeping them in a cool, dry spot
Different Takes For Each Season
Summer: Mix in some crushed freeze-dried strawberries for extra zing
Fall: Add a dash of cinnamon to the dough
Winter: Sprinkle crushed candy canes on top
Spring: Switch to white chocolate and pink marshmallows
Fixing Common Problems
If your marshmallows melt too much and run everywhere, try putting them right in the middle of each cookie. When cookies flatten out too much, chill the dough longer or add a spoonful more flour. If your chocolate stays chunky, try cutting it into smaller pieces.
Planning Ahead
Get ready for a party by:
- Mixing the dough up to 2 days before
- Getting all your toppings measured out ahead of time
- Setting out all your tools before you start baking
- Finding a good spot for cookies to cool down
More Than Just Tasty Treats
Brings families closer together
Shows kids how fun baking can be
Creates times you'll remember forever
Teaches kids to wait patiently while dough chills and marshmallows toast
My little girl once told me these cookies taste like "summer hugs" and that's so true. Just making them brings our family together just like sitting around a campfire does.
After playing around with this recipe for years, I've found the real special thing isn't just how they taste like s'mores, but how they bring people together. Whether you share them at a birthday party or pack them for a day at the park, they always make people smile and create happy moments. Just remember, cookies always taste better when they're made with love and shared with friends!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why chill the dough beforehand?
- Cold dough spreads less while baking and makes the cookies taste better.
- → Can you keep these in the freezer?
- For sure, stash baked ones (no toppings) in the freezer up to 3 months.
- → Can dough be prepped in advance?
- You bet! Refrigerate it up to 3 days or freeze for 3 months.
- → Are toasted marshmallows necessary?
- Nope, but they'll give that authentic s'mores taste.
- → What's the best way to store them?
- Use a sealed container, keep them at room temperature, and enjoy within 5 days.