Pin it
This incredible mix of silky mac and cheese with tangy-hot honey pepper chicken makes a mouthwatering comfort dish you won't forget. From the crunchy chicken to the velvety cheese blend, each component works together in this Applebee's copycat that'll quickly become your family's go-to favorite.
I found out that letting the honey pepper mix bubble away for a full 15 minutes really makes all the difference in getting that authentic Applebee's sticky glaze. Just last month, my kids asked for this instead of restaurant food for their birthday dinner - pretty solid proof this homemade version hits the spot.
Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice
- Pasta: Go for textured cavatappi or elbow macaroni that trap all that cheese sauce in their twists. Fresh works wonders, though dried holds up nicely when stored
- Cheese Blend: Grab blocks and grate them yourself instead of using pre-packaged stuff for the creamiest results. The mix of sharp cheddar, mozzarella, and Parmesan adds amazing flavor layers
- Chicken: Pick pieces that are roughly the same size so they cook evenly. When buying ready-made, get plain strips so they'll soak up more honey pepper sauce
- Heavy Cream: Don't skimp with the full-fat version for that silky-smooth sauce. Never swap it for milk or half-and-half
Step-by-Step Cooking Method
- 1. Getting Chicken Just Right
- Add salt and pepper to your chicken strips. Heat your oil to 350°F in a big pan. Cook them 4-5 minutes each side until they turn golden and hit 165°F inside. Move them to a wire rack after cooking. This keeps them crispy all around.
- 2. Whipping Up Honey Pepper Sauce
- Mix all sauce stuff in a pot over medium heat. Keep an eye on it as it starts to boil – honey can bubble over fast. Turn the heat down right away and keep it at a low bubble. Give it a stir every few minutes so it doesn't stick. It's ready when it coats your spoon nicely.
- 3. Getting Pasta Right
- Boil your pasta in really salty water until it's just firm. Save 1 cup of that starchy water before draining. Don't rinse the pasta – that starch helps the sauce stick better. Toss the drained pasta with a bit of olive oil so it doesn't clump up.
- 4. Creating the Cheese Sauce
- Start by melting butter with cream on low heat to avoid splitting. Add your cheese bit by bit, stirring all the time. If it gets too thick, splash in some of that saved pasta water a little at a time. You want it smooth and flowing, not stringy or lumpy.
- 5. Putting It All Together
- Mix the bacon into your cheese sauce first, then add pasta. This spreads it out better. Dunk each chicken piece in the honey pepper sauce, letting extra drip off. Fill bowls with your cheesy pasta, place glazed chicken on top, and finish with fresh basil and some black pepper.
Pin it
My family's little trick for amazing cheese sauce is throwing in a tiny bit of nutmeg – it boosts the cheese flavor without anyone noticing it's there. We tried so many versions, and this small change really made it special.
Keeping Everything at the Right Heat
Getting temperatures just right matters a ton. Start with furiously boiling water for pasta, keep your oil at exactly 350°F for crunchy chicken, and never let that cheese sauce boil. Cool your chicken for about 5 minutes at room temp before adding sauce or it'll slide right off. Watch your honey pepper sauce like a hawk while it cooks down to get that perfect thickness.
Pin it
Getting Your Ingredients Ready
Having everything prepped makes life easier. Shred your cheese while waiting for water to boil, cook bacon ahead of time, and measure out all honey pepper sauce ingredients. This keeps your cheese sauce from breaking and stops pasta from turning mushy. Pour measured liquids into small containers for easy adding.
Prep-Ahead Options
Make different parts ahead for quick assembly later. Cook bacon and mix up honey pepper sauce up to three days early. Your cheese sauce can be warmed up again with a splash of extra cream. Cook pasta slightly underdone if you'll reheat it later. Store your chicken pieces uncovered in the fridge to keep them crispy.
Ways to Serve It Up
Bring it to the table on one big platter or in separate bowls. Top with some fresh basil, extra bacon bits, and a little warm honey pepper sauce drizzled over. Serve right away while the cheese sauce is hot and runny. Keep some extra sauce warmed up for anyone who wants more.
How to Handle Leftovers
Keep everything separate – pasta with cheese sauce in one container, chicken in another. Warm up the pasta mix on low heat with a bit of cream added. Put chicken in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes to make it crispy again. Whip up fresh honey pepper sauce, since stored sauce gets too thick.
Pin it
Wrapping Up
This fancy mac and cheese takes a popular restaurant dish and makes it even better at home. The combo of perfectly cooked pasta, rich cheese sauce, crunchy chicken, and that amazing honey pepper glaze creates something that's both cozy and exciting. The secret to nailing it is taking your time with each part and watching those temperatures carefully.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is fresh cheese better than pre-shredded?
- Yes, fresh cheese melts smoother. Pre-shredded has coatings that might mess with the texture.
- → Can I prep it the day before?
- You can make the sauces early, but mix them fresh when serving. Reheated cheese may split.
- → How much heat does this pack?
- Barely a kick from cayenne. Adjust spices to your liking.
- → Will other pasta shapes work?
- Definitely—medium pastas like spirals grab the sauce best.
- → No pineapple juice available. What now?
- Swap it for orange or apple juice, but the taste might slightly change.